Revisiting R22 Replacements options - Comparison between R22, R404A, R448A, R407A and R407H
Recently, many types of low GWP refrigerants are being promoted to reduce global warming in the global HVAC/R market and to eliminate R22 use. As the optimal refrigerant for each application is different depending on application type, capacity and temperature range, and safety requirement, it is important to have diversity of refrigerant choice. Globally and in the US the commercial refrigeration industry is in a transition to refrigerants below a global warming potential of 1500 to meet regulatory requirements. A new Class A1 refrigerant blend in the R407 series was developed, R407H, to meet this requirement for commercial refrigeration applications. To evaluate the performance of the blend in medium and low temperature conditions a comparison was performed at Creative Thermal Solutions (Urbana, IL) utilizing a refrigeration laboratory. The laboratory was instrumented to ASHRAE 72 standard requirements and consists of varying capacity, VFD controlled, tandem scroll compressors, coupled with a controlled condenser and running a set of 5 cases with a combined LT load of 2.98kW and combined medium temperature load of 7.86kW. The equipment selected was standard R22/R404A equipment. The system was controlled by an Emerson E2 in combination with LabVIEW and HP Datalogging. The system was baselined with R22 and a comparison was made to R404A, R407A, R448A and R407H. The system was analyzed both as a nominal “Drop-In” and with minor optimizations. System effects due to glide, such as frosting, condenser and evaporator efficiency were analyzed and potential control parameters proposed and evaluated. In conclusion it was determined that R407H utilizing traditional R407 refrigerant chemistry without any additional HFO, Hydrocarbon or CO2 components is suitable as a replacement for existing R22 and R404A systems reaching expected efficiency targets while providing the benefits associated with well studied chemistries at the target GWP.
--- Datum: 15.10.2018 Uhrzeit: 13:15 - 13:45 Uhr Ort: Raum Kiew, NCC Ost